Muslims who want to
modernize The Islamic world By Philip Bowring (IHT) Thursday, October 23, 2003
The task may be impossible. The OIC is a gathering of 57 countries with
Muslim majorities or large minorities. Thus it represents states rather
than the broader ummah, or Islamic community. At the political level it is
extremely difficult for them to find common ground on anything except the
West's anti-Muslim prejudices and Palestine. Even on Palestine there was
an underlying sense of frustration at the failure of Arab states to put
support for Palestinians ahead of survival of their socially and
technologically backward regimes.
But this gathering of Muslim heads of state and government - the
biggest ever, and the first OIC summit meeting since Sept. 11, 2001 -
helped concentrate minds on issues often forgotten by Muslims and
Westerners alike.
It was a reminder that most Muslims live east of Iran in countries in
which they are either a minority, such as India, or where there are large
non-Muslim minorities, such as Indonesia and Malaysia.
Arabs account for only about 20 percent of all Muslims. The Arabic
language and Mecca give Arabs a special position in the Muslim world, and
in recent years oil money and the sheer number of Arab petty states have
had added to their influence in Islamic institutions. This influence of
socially and technologically backward states is not appreciated in Muslim
states and communities that regard themselves as more progressive, focused
on economic and social advancement not on rituals and dogmas.
Faced with the generalized anti-Muslim sentiment which had long existed
in the West but has risen to often hysterical levels since the Sept. 11
attacks, Muslims from elsewhere are seeing the need to focus on
self-improvement as well as grievances.
This expressed itself in a number of ways at the OIC meeting. First,
the Malaysians repeatedly delivered reminders that the road to respect is,
as during the glorious days of Islam, through the advancement of science
and learning. Fixation with dress codes, rather than modern knowledge, has
been the cause of backwardness.
Second, there was recognition that Islam is the only major religion to
have been started by a trader, the Prophet Muhammad. Christians and
Confucians may have been suspicious of the values of merchants, but
Muhammad gave an honorable place to industry and commerce. Yet most
Islamic nations west of Pakistan have economies that are as closed to
trade with fellow Muslims as they are with everyone else.
Talk of an eventual Islamic common market or Islamic currency was the
kind of impractical dream of which such gatherings are made. But it served
as a useful reminder that the economic policies of several Middle East
countries owe more to Marx or feudalism than to teachings of the trader
Muhammad. Islam has no alternative to, or conflict with, modern economics.
Even Islamic banking, which anyway only a minority of Muslims require, is
easily compatible with interest-based systems.
The trade and learning needs of the ummah were underlined here by an
OIC Business Forum. The first of its kind, it featured as speakers such
recent converts to foreign investment as the president of Sudan.
Pakistan's president, Pervez Musharraf, spoke at length of the need for
private-sector economic leadership and the merits of free trade and
capital.
Pan-Islamic trade groups are not going to happen. Any trade pacts
involving OIC members will be based on geography, not religion. But at the
level of individuals and of firms, the ummah may have a role to play in
breaking down the nation-state fortress mentality that is strong in the
Middle East, but less so in the eastern Islamic world. Any talk of the
importance of trade, technology and investment rather than politics and
grievances is a step forward.
Malaysia cunningly sought to expand the OIC's relevance by inviting two
heads of state with significant - and rebellious - Muslim inhabitants,
Presidents Vladimir Putin of Russia and Gloria Arroyo of the Philippines.
Given the growth of Muslim minorities in Europe and the United States,
will Presidents Jacques Chirac and George W. Bush be guests at the OIC's
next meeting?
If nothing else, Malaysia's efforts as summit impresario may have given
the OIC a chance to be relevant. |
Subscriptions E-mail Alerts | About the IHT : Privacy & Cookies : Contact the IHT |